
I have very little to add to the very smart online discourse surrounding Thomas Kail's live capture of Hamilton currently streaming on Disney+, but will ramble for a moment anyway. I had seen it live in San Francisco last April (and I won the ticket lottery so was in the damn orchestra!) with a fantastic cast, and I definitely preferred our Hamilton Julius Thomas III's singing voice to Lin-Manuel Miranda's, as charming as Miranda is onscreen. But what pleasure to see that insanely talented Broadway cast up close and personal, with Daveed Diggs in particular absolutely running away with every scene he appears in. Like the rest of the country I am thinking way more critically than even a year ago about how the white enslavers are portrayed in the musical, and Miranda himself this week described criticisms of how he handled slavery as valid. The optismism palpable in the onscreen production (filmed in June 2016) is almost physically painful too, given all that has transpired since then. However, one of Hamilton's greatest achievements is its reclaiming and remixing of history, and now with it readily accessible to anyone who can afford Disney+, not just those who could pony up $$$ for a ticket, the narrative is further democratized. And I will forever love Miranda for giving Eliza the last gasp.
See also: