Janet Cardiff has long been one of my favorite artists, ever since one of her site-specific audio walks brought me literally to tears at SFMOMA soon after I first moved to the city. Since then I've sought out her work in London and in New York, and as I wrote in my Collection Rotation I even named my cat after her. Cardiff's work with her partner George Bures Miller often takes the form of rich, music-accented multimedia installations that play with ideas of storytelling and memory, and they currently have a show up at Modern Art Oxford called The House of Books Has No Windows, named after the piece pictured right which is one of seven installations on display there. Adrian Searle, however, in his review of the show feels like the duo work better with simpler concepts and that some of the more complex works can be overwrought:
Opera for a Small Room is something of a tour de force. Inspired, in
part, by an old collection of opera LPs found in a sale, its most
salient influences were apparently Krapp's Last Tape, by Samuel
Beckett, and Wim Wenders' film Wings of Desire. But an artwork can be
less than the sum of its influences. To me, the unavoidable model for
the unseen narrator is less Beckett's Krapp, with his old spools of
memories, or the old man in Wenders and Peter Handke's filmic homage to
Berlin, than Tom Waits, with his ruinous voice, his rancid memories and
stewed regrets. He don't need no installation. He can do it all in a
song.
I might have to disagree with Searle as I love teasing out the layers of meaning involved in a detailed installation, though I also enjoy the subtle shifts in perspective that occur on the more stripped-down audio walks with only Cardiff's voice in my ears. For more pictures from the Oxford show, please click here. As for me, I'm going to try to sneak out at lunch to go do The Telephone Call at SFMOMA, currently available as part of their Art of Participation exhibit. More on that later.